So basically :
From top to bottom
2" talalay soft
3" Dunlop medium firm
6" pocketed coils
6" Dunlop solid core
Does this seem like an overkill ? With the solid core and the 6" pocketed coils
That’s quite a layered setup! It sounds like you’re aiming for a balance of comfort and support.
The 2" Talalay soft layer will give you that plush feel on top, while the 3" Dunlop medium firm adds some support.
The pocketed coils provide good responsiveness and airflow, and the solid core will help with durability and stability.
It sounds like a bit overkill to me though. 17" of mattress plus the cover, so you are close to 18". Why not reduce the the 6" dunlop solid core down to 2" and use it as a base layer, and and you will have a nice 14" mattress that will probably serve you just as well, unless there is something you are not revealing. Such as some of these layers are being reused from some other set up to save costs.
On the down side.
Placing a 6" Dunlop solid core underneath 6" of pocketed coils can lead to several potential issues. The solid core may create an excessively firm base, counteracting the softness and cushioning of the coils and upper layers, which could result in an uncomfortable sleeping surface. A solid core can reduce the responsiveness of the pocketed coils; these coils are designed to adapt to pressure and movement, and a rigid base might hinder that adaptability, making the mattress feel less conforming to your body’s contours.
Heat retention is another concern, as a solid core can trap heat more than a more ventilated base, potentially leading to a warmer sleeping environment, which may not be ideal for those who sleep hot.
The overall weight of such a thick setup can make the mattress cumbersome to move or adjust, complicating tasks like changing sheets or repositioning it.
Depending on the quality and construction of the solid core, there is a risk of sagging over time, which could compromise the overall support and comfort of the mattress. If you’re are set to this design, it might be worth considering a thinner core as I mentioned, or a different material that allows for better airflow and flexibility while still providing adequate support.
In an odd sort of way, this setup is reminiscent of Saatva’s dual spring layer design in their Classic mattress. They feature an innerspring support core with a pocketed coil layer on top. While some people enjoy this combination, there are also plenty of complaints about comfort and support. Your configuration is clearly different, but it shares that dual-core concept.
Your design, with a solid Dunlop core beneath pocketed coils, embodies that dual-core spirit, but might take it a step further in terms of firmness and support. While it could offer great durability and a unique feel, it also runs the risk of sacrificing some responsiveness and comfort if the layers don’t work together as intended. It’s all about finding the right balance for your specific needs and preferences.
Have you tried this already, or is this a bit of a new brainstorming thought process?
Best of luck to you, whatever you choose and would love to hear some follow up.
Maverick.
1 Like
Yeah, it sounds like you should choose between the latex core or the pocket coils. I have the 8 inch TPS 15.5 coils, 2 inches of firm talalay latex and then 3 pounds inches of talalay (vzone “zoned”) and it is plenty supportive, yet comfortable.
1 Like