Hi ewilv,
Welcome to the Mattress UnderGround. We are happy to have you here.
Since you’re mainly a back sleeper and prefer a medium-firm feel, a hybrid mattress could be an excellent option for you. Hybrids offer a balance of support from innerspring coils with the comfort of foam or latex layers, which is ideal if you change positions throughout the night. The @DLX hybrid you mentioned is solid choice, as hybrids tend to provide good pressure relief, helping to alleviate back and neck pain and DLX makes an excellent quality mattress and offers a generous trial period with excellent customer service.
Regarding the Avocado mattress, it’s a well-regarded option known for its natural materials like organic latex and wool, which provide a durable and eco-friendly product. However, it’s important to know that many users report that the Avocado tends to feel firmer than other mattresses in its category. This is not a bad thing or a good thing, it is simply what others have mentioned when purchasing an Avocado. From a construction standpoint, Avocado is solid choice. It may feel a bit harder than expected, especially if you’re used to a softer feel. While its trial period and return policy are beneficial, the firmness might not align perfectly with your preferences. If you find that it’s too firm, you could always adjust the feel by adding a mattress topper, which could provide that extra softness you’re seeking.
As others may have suggested to you, testing a mattress in person can offer some insight as to whether the mattress you are considering is too soft. When a mattress seems a bit firm, that is where it can get a bit tricky. Most foam incorporated mattresses will soften over time, even natural latex. As you trial your mattress, you need to take that into consideration and allow your trial to run its course as you may feel differently in week 3 than you did in week 1. Of course, there is no substitute for experiencing a new mattress in your home environment, regardless of what it felt like in the showroom.
A mattress’s firmness can feel different based on the setting. Also, since you sometimes share your bed with your sister and dog, finding a mattress that minimizes motion transfer will enhance the sleep experience for both of you, ensuring you aren’t disturbed by any shifts in position.
Understanding you have a budget of $1.5K, you have many high-quality options to consider, but it’s important to remember to budget for extras like a mattress protector or topper if needed. If temperature regulation is a concern—especially with your sister being a hot sleeper, you might want to prioritize hybrids that offer good airflow.
The key point for you is that the mattress offers support, posture and alignment, and the pressure relief you prefer. Regarding the the DLX classic hybrid it is a dual sided mattress that will add extended longevity to your mattress experience.
Based on what your research has revealed, you are on the right track. You just need to determine if you prefer the all natural option mattress. If you have reservations regarding Avocado, as a natural choice, @My_Green_Mattress offers a similar construction and is within your budget.
All the best, if you have any questions about a mattress from any of the trusted members here at TMU, you can just use the @symbol as a prefix to the trusted member’s name like @Maverick and they will respond to you.
Maverick.