New, overwhelmed, and restless

Hello!

As stated, I am new to looking for mattresses and quite overwhelmed by all the options, so I am hoping this brief summary will help someone help me!

I’m 35 years old, 5’11, around 160lbs, sleep on my back and on my side(s). I run hot usually. And… I have back pain issues. If I’m in bed sick for a whole day, my back will kill me the next day. Fun. I want to say I like soft vs really firm (though I do not know which would be best for my condition), so I have no particular preference at this time, but if it matters, I enjoy softer more. I haven’t been able to try many “modern” mattresses so not sure on materials. The only ones I was able to try were a few Purple mattresses and I enjoyed the feel of those (not sure about extended period of time). Looking for a queen bed not entirely sure on the budget yet, but certain would like to get an exceptional experience. I wouldn’t mind one from one of the experts or someone local (especially if I can try some out). I’m in Orange County, California. Any help and recommendations would be much appreciated! Thanks in advance!

1 Like

Hi SGX,

Welcome to the Mattress UnderGround!

When searching for a new mattress, it’s easy to get overwhelmed by marketing hype. To make an informed decision, focus on the key components of a mattress and understand their roles. The mattress has three primary layers: the support layer, the comfort layer, and the cover layer.

The support layer forms the foundation of the mattress and provides essential support for your body. This can be made from innerspring coils or dense foam. Innerspring coils offer a traditional feel and effective support, with the coil gauge (thickness) and count impacting comfort and durability. Dense foam, which includes high-density polyfoam or memory foam, offers support and usually lasts longer with higher density.

On top of the support layer is the comfort layer, which provides cushioning and impacts pressure relief, spinal alignment, and overall comfort. Memory foam is known for its ability to conform to your body shape and relieve pressure, although it retains heat. Latex foam offers a bouncy, responsive feel while providing good support and durability. Polyfoam, a less expensive option, varies in softness and support based on its density. Layers like wool and cotton often found in premium and luxury mattresses for some is the best option.

The cover layer, the outermost part of the mattress, affects the initial feel and may include additional padding. It is typically made from materials such as cotton, which is breathable and soft, or polyester blends, which are durable and often enhance the mattress’s softness. Some covers feature special fabrics with cooling technologies or extra padding for added comfort.

For a practical demonstration of how these components work together, take a look at this video on the Purple mattress. It provides a clear view of the internal layers and construction, helping you understand how different materials interact. The video specifically highlights how lower-quality gels, grids, and gimmicks often fail to live up to the hype they promise.

When choosing a mattress, it’s essential to consider material transparency. Look for detailed information on foam densities, spring gauges, and firmness levels (Indentation Load Deflection, or ILD). This information helps you evaluate quality and durability. If possible, test the mattress in-store to assess comfort and support, or take advantage of online trial periods, which often last 90-120 nights, allowing you to try the mattress at home and return it if necessary.

Additionally, research customer reviews and expert ratings to gauge long-term performance, paying attention to feedback on durability and comfort. Consider whether accessories like adjustable bases or mattress toppers might enhance your sleep experience, as adjustable bases can improve support and allow for customizable positions.

Balancing these factors—posture and alignment, pressure relief, and personal preferences—along with understanding the mattress’s construction and materials will help you find a solution that meets your needs.

In your area, you might want to consider Custom Comfort. Although they aren’t a Trusted Member here, they excel at creating custom mattresses tailored to individual preferences.

If you’re open to exploring options in San Diego or north towards Santa Barbara, you’ll find excellent choices from some of our Trusted Members.

That said, don’t overlook some of the high-quality Bed-in-a-Box (BiB) options available in the USA. Many of these manufacturers produce excellent mattresses that are compressed, rolled, and shipped directly to your home. These can often surpass older brands that have compromised on quality in favor of profit.

Given your height and weight, you have a wide range of options. Whether you prefer a traditional or a more modern mattress style, you should be able to find something that meets your specific needs.

All the best,

Maverick

@BackScience
@Arizona_Premium
@Sleep_EZ
@DLX
@My_Green_Mattress
@EngineeredSleep

2 Likes

I would be happy to help! @Maverick did a great job of breaking things down for you, but I will also add some insight here. If you like the feel overall of a Purple mattress, then you would fit well with a more buoyant hybrid gel style mattress like Back Science.

That Back Science mattress offers more of a body contouring pressure relief and support vs. a traditional quilted mattress that has that more pillow type comfort due to the fiber-filled top or a memory foam mattress that will contour extremely well, but may not have enough buoyancy to give you the back support you need. With Back Science, I was able to use the Mattress Checker App.

I created it to determine the best way to properly zone a mattress to give the most optimal support, but it was also its patented Airflow Transfer System combined with the Hypergel surface that helps it retain a cooler response as verified by our most recent 3rd party survey. Anyway, feel free to respond here or message me if you have any questions and if you get a minute, take a look at the information on the @BackScience page to learn more about the mattress.

Woah thank you so much for such detailed! I think you just condensed the whole experience in a few paragraphs. I certainly wouldn’t mind going to SD to check some stuff out. I do feel like I need a test drive with some. With the little info you have of me, would there be any DIY or BiB options you would nudge me towards that have worked for others? Either way thanks a lot for the assist!

Any of the @xyz options I mentioned would be excellent choices. The mattress market can be overwhelming, it really is a jungle out there. With companies like 3z Brands (Brooklyn Bedding, Helix, Birch, and their other sister brands), Diamond Mattress, Naturepedic, private independents like Bowles Mattress and spencers ventura mattress, among others offering high-quality products, it makes sense to consider one of the Trusted Members here at TMU.

The @'s I listed at the end of your first post offer personalized collaboration for any project, whether DIY or pre-configured. They’re reliable and vetted sources, delivering top-notch quality. When you use the TMU promocode, they’re especially motivated to ensure you’re satisfied, as they take pride in their work and in receiving praise for their exceptional mattress matching, similar to how @BackScience is recognized for the Mattress Checker App and the mattresses they design. They’re dedicated to getting it right a very high percentage of the time (well into the 90th percentile), otherwise, you’d be back here seeking further “clarification.”

While no one can predict exactly how a mattress will feel for you personally, these experts excel at forecasting your likely match based on the information you provide.

Although I’m very satisfied with my firm Plank Luxe from Brooklyn Bedding over the past two years, I’m quite intrigued by the Back Science Series 2 for a guest room. It seems to check a lot of boxes. I have already purchased and advised friends to purchase from a few Trusted Members and they dont even know it. I like to “keep them honest” as they say.

Choosing a mattress is quite personal and subjective, which is why mattress trials are so valuable. You can’t fully gauge how a mattress will perform from a showroom trial, except to weed out those that are too soft. Relying on specifications and advice from knowledgeable customer service professionals gives you a better chance of finding the right mattress. That’s why having transparent specifications is so crucial.

Good luck on the search,

You have a lot of options.

Maverick

1 Like